Work to do, build on your Potential, well on your way: what each band means
The quiz turns your total into one of three bands. Work to Do means you rarely use the behaviors it lists. Build on Your Potential means you use some of them, some of the time.
Well on Your Way means you use most of them often. Mindtools shows your band on the results screen, and that screen is the one to trust. It does not print the cutoffs in the quiz text.
Copies of the quiz shared online put the lines at 34 and 52 points out of 90, but treat those numbers as unofficial. If your version uses the same lines, try this sum.
Not at all counts as one point and Very often as five, so answering Sometimes to all 18 statements gives 54 points, just inside the top band. In other words, you can reach Well on Your Way by doing each good habit about half the time.
So read below the band. Add up each area, then divide by its number of statements, so support and stimulation is not counted double. You now have eight averages on the same one-to-five scale.
Circle the lowest two. Those are the result. If two areas tie, pick the one your team would notice first if it improved.
Use this worksheet. Score each answer 1 (Not at all) to 5 (Very often), add up the statements in each area, then divide by the number of statements.
| Area | Statements | Your sum | Divide by | Your average (1 to 5) |
|---|
| Self-confidence | 2, 8 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Positive attitude and outlook | 10, 17 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Emotional intelligence | 5, 15 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Providing a compelling vision | 6, 14 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Motivating people to deliver the vision | 9, 12 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Being a good role model | 4, 11 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Managing performance effectively | 3, 13 | ____ | 2 | ____ |
|---|
| Providing support and stimulation | 1, 7, 16, 18 | ____ | 4 | ____ |
|---|
What if I score low on the Mindtools leadership quiz?
A low total on a quiz you score yourself can mean two things, and just one concerns skill. It may mean you are new to leading and have not built the habits yet, which is normal in your first year with direct reports. It may also mean you judge yourself harshly.
People who take their own ratings seriously often mark lower than people who skim. Neither one means you cannot lead.
Use the low score the same way as any other: find the two weakest areas and start with one. A low score gives you a clear starting point, which a middling one often does not.
Are leadership self-assessments actually accurate?
Mindtools is open about the limits. Under the quiz it says: "This assessment has not been validated and is intended for illustrative purposes only." In plain terms, nobody has checked whether high scorers lead better, or whether a retake gives a similar score.
Treat the score as a way to spot habits worth a closer look. It cannot tell you how well you lead.
Self-ratings in general run high for a known reason. The research term is social desirability: when you rate yourself, you drift toward the answer a good manager would give, usually without noticing. The Mindtools format makes this easy.
Each statement describes a plainly good habit, so the wished-for answer is obvious. You are free to mark Often on every line, and nothing costs you anything when you do.
Most of us also rate our intentions. We remember the week we held every one-to-one and forget the month we cancelled half of them.
What if my self-assessment doesn't match how others see me?
Mindtools names this as the widest gap in leadership self-assessment: the space between your own view and the way others experience you. A gap is common. It does not mean you fooled yourself, and it does not mean your team is right about everything either.
Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall argue in Harvard Business Review that a colleague's score reflects their own standards as much as your behavior. What helps is detail. Take the statements behind your two lowest areas and ask three people who watch you work most weeks to rate you on just those.
Where your number and theirs differ by two points or more, ask each person for one example. The examples are what you act on. If you want to do this in a more formal way, the federal government's personnel office explains how its leadership development assessments gather ratings from a leader's supervisor, peers, and direct reports, while our 360 personality assessment guide covers setting one up yourself.